Should Vegans Eat Insects?

vegans

When I’ve told some of my friends about my slightly unusual hobby of cooking insects, they replied with a,   “Oh man…that’s why I’m a vegan…” This, dear vegan friends, brings up an interesting inquiry: If the ultimate goal of a vegan is to reduce the harm done to animals, then an exclusively plant-based diet is not the answer.

Here’s the dilemma: Vegans don’t eat animals, insects are animals, so vegans don’t eat insects. The end. But this  overly simple syllogism does not entertain the very real possibility that vegans, by the nature of their quest to reduce animal suffering, may not only be permitted to eat insects—they may be obligated to do so. Let’s break down this argument bullet-point style:

This is the agricultural reality that we all too often ignore. Vegans might respond that incidental animal deaths caused from growing crops is ethically superior to directly killing animals to make burgers. Or that vegan-friendly farming techniques are being developed.

  • Hans Smid, expert on the brains of parasitic wasps (some of the most behaviorally sophisticated insects on Earth) told the Washington Post, “that insects do not feel pain.”
  • Robert Elwood, professor of the biological sciences, notes that pain would provide insects no evolutionary advantages. The only reason for pain is that it enables long-term protection, but the average lifespan of a field cricket is a few weeks—its “protection” comes from its remarkable reproductive efficiency, not its ability to learn from mistakes through pain.
  • If vegans are still unsure whether insects suffer, then they run a small risk. If they stick to a plant-based diet they ensure animals definitely will suffer.

As James McWilliams, brilliant vegan author, writes, “As a longtime vegan and vegan advocate, I’m well aware how this argument threatens the vegan identity. Of course, it’s much easier to declare, “I don’t eat animals or animal products” than it is to blur the lines that serve as clear ethical commandments. But as the prospect of eating insects gains traction, vegans may be forced to acknowledge the inconvenient fact that including these critters in our diet—yes, eating animals—is an essential way to achieve the ultimate vegan goal of reducing the suffering of animals who we know can suffer…

The more vegans replaced plant-based calories with insect-based calories, the fewer animals they’d end up harming. This is the vegan’s dilemma.”

 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s